Tillage effects on humus content in the soils of Ukraine: A meta-analysis of current scientific evidence
Abstract
Tillage is an agrotechnological factor with the strongest influence on soil properties, especially, agrophysical and agrochemical ones. Soil fertility depends on numerous soil traits, but mainly on the content of humus (soil organic matter). The current food crisis and the aggravation of negative climate impacts on environmental systems require a scientifically sound reaction of current agriculture to future challenges. Adoption of optimal tillage practices is crucial for the preservation of soil health and, consequently, for food security. The study is devoted to the meta-analysis of current scientific evidence on optimal tillage systems for Ukrainian soils in terms of humus content preservation. The meta-analysis was carried out through the standardized mean differences algorithm. The average effect size was calculated by the Cohen’s distance. Publication biases were estimated using fail-safe numbers. The heterogeneity of the studies was estimated by Higgins coefficient the Chi2 homogeneity test. Only robust domestic scientific studies were included in the meta-analysis. To search for scientific publications, the Google Scholar engine was applied. In general, 18 eligible studies out of more than 50 were enrolled and processed. It was established that there is not sufficient scientific evidence in favour of no-till systems in Ukraine. The meta-analysis provided inconclusive results because of lack of high-quality scientific research, high bias of publications and high intra-studies variability. As for the comparison between conventional ploughing and ploughless tillage systems, strong evidence was established in favour of ploughless tillage. Notwithstanding the subtle general effects size of 0.24, it was statistically significant at 95% confidence interval. Low heterogeneity and intra-studies variability strengthen the evidence in favour of ploughless tillage without soil layer inversion. More thorough scientific investigations should be performed to provide more evidence on the benefits of zero-tillage systems on Ukrainian soils.References
Alexander, R. A., Scozzaro, M. J., & Borodkin, L. J. (1989). Statistical and empirical examination of the chi-square test for homogeneity of correlations in meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 106(2), 329.
Angers, D. A., & Eriksen-Hamel, N. S. (2008). Full-inversion tillage and organic carbon distribution in soil profiles: A meta-analysis. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 72(5), 1370–1374.
Ariel de Lima, D., Helito, C. P., Lima, L. L. D., Clazzer, R., Gonçalves, R. K., & Camargo, O. P. D. (2022). How to perform a meta-analysis: a practical step-by-step guide using R software and R Studio. Acta Ortopedica Brasileira, 30(3), e248775.
Balayev, A. D., Havrylyuk, M. V., & Stopa, V. P. (2013). Rodiuchist chornozemiv Lisostepu za vykorystannia minimizatsii obrobitku gruntu i elementiv biolohizatsii zemlerobstva [Fertility of Forest-Steppe chernozems under use of minimizing tillage and elements of biologization in agriculture]. Herald of Kharkiv National Agrarian University named after V. V. Dokuchaiev, Series: Soil Science, Agrochemistry, Agriculture, Forestry, Soil Ecology, 1, 8–11 (in Ukrainian).
Beheshti, A., Chavanon, M. L., & Christiansen, H. (2020). Emotion dysregulation in adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: A meta-analysis. BMC Psychiatry, 20(1), 1–11.
Bogonos, M., Nivievskyi, O., Martyshev, P., Neyter, R., Kolodiazhnyi, I., Litvinov, V., Piddubnyi, I., & Stolnikovich, H. (2023). Agriculture in Ukraine: Pre-war, status quo and a look ahead. KSE Agrocenter, Kyiv.
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L. V., Higgins, J. P., & Rothstein, H. R. (2021). Introduction to meta-analysis. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Castellini, M., Diacono, M., Gattullo, C. E., & Stellacci, A. M. (2021). Sustainable agriculture and soil conservation. Applied Sciences, 11(9), 4146.
Chernilevskyi, M. S., Meleshko, O. P., & Havrylov, S. O. (2001). Minimalizatsiia osnovnoho obrobitku gruntu – vazhlyvyi zakhid biolohizatsiyi zemlerobstva [Minimization of tillage as an important measure of agricultural biologization]. Herald of State Agroecological Academy of Ukraine, 1, 103–105 (in Ukrainian).
Chernilevskyi, M. S., Rybak, M. F., Biliavskyi, Y. A., & Sayuk, O. A. (1998). Vplyv sposobiv osnovnoho obrobitku na ekolohichnyi stan gruntu i vrozhainist’ sil’s’kohospodarskykh kul’tur [Effect of soil tillage on ecological conditions of the soil and yields of crops]. Herald of State Agroecological Academy of Ukraine, 2, 33–39 (in Ukrainian).
Cooper, J., Baranski, M., Stewart, G., Nobel-de Lange, M., Bàrberi, P., Fließbach, A., Peigne, J., Berner, A., Brock, C., Casagrande, M., Crowley, O., David, C., De Vliegher, A., Doring, T. F., Dupont, A., Entz, M., Grosse, M., Haase, T., Halde, C., Hammerl, V., Huiting, H., Leithold, G., Messmer, M., Schloter, M., Sukkel, W., van der Heijden, M. G. A., Willekens, K., Wittwer, R., & Mäder, P. (2016). Shallow non-inversion tillage in organic farming maintains crop yields and increases soil C stocks: A meta-analysis. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 36, 1–20.
Crystal-Ornelas, R., Thapa, R., & Tully, K. L. (2021). Soil organic carbon is affected by organic amendments, conservation tillage, and cover cropping in organic farming systems: A meta-analysis. Agriculture, Acosystems and Environment, 312, 107356.
Ding, W., Li, J., Ma, H., Wu, Y., & He, H. (2023). Science mapping of meta-analysis in agricultural science. Information, 14(11), 611.
Ellis, P. D. (2010). The essential guide to effect sizes: Statistical power, meta-analysis, and the interpretation of research results. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Evtushenko, T. V., & Tonha, O. L. (2017). Umist i zapasy humusu zalezhno vid udobrenniya i obrobitku chornozemu typovoho [Content and stock of humus, depending on fertilization and treatment of the soil of chernozem of typical]. Scientific Reports of the National University of Environmental and Life Sciences of Ukraine, 269, 168–176 (in Ukrainian).
Githongo, M. W., Kiboi, M. N., Ngetich, F. K., Musafiri, C. M., Muriuki, A., & Fliessbach, A. (2021). The effect of minimum tillage and animal manure on maize yields and soil organic carbon in sub-Saharan Africa: A meta-analysis. Environmental Challenges, 5, 100340.
Gordienko, V. P., & Shevchenko, I. M. (2013). Zmina vmistu zahal’noho humusu v grunti za riznykh system udobrennia i obrobitku ta vrozhainist’ ozymoyi pshenytsi [Тhe content of soil humus under various systems of fertilizer and tillage]. Scientific Collection of the Southern branch of the National University of Environmental and Life Sciences of Ukraine, Series: Agricultural Sciences, 154, 120–125 (in Ukrainian).
Haddaway, N. R., Hedlund, K., Jackson, L. E., Kätterer, T., Lugato, E., Thomsen, I. K., Jorgensen, H. B., & Isberg, P. E. (2017). How does tillage intensity affect soil organic carbon? A systematic review. Environmental Evidence, 6, 1–48.
He, C., Niu, J. R., Xu, C. T., Han, S. W., Bai, W., Song, Q. L., Dang, Y. P., & Zhang, H. L. (2022). Effect of conservation tillage on crop yield and soil organic carbon in Northeast China: A meta-analysis. Soil Use and Management, 38(2), 1146–1161.
Hlushchenko, L. D., Len, O. I., & Olepir, R. V. (2024). Enerhozberihaiuchi sposoby osnovnoho obrobitku gruntu pry vyroshchuvanni pshenytsi ozymoyi ta yikh vplyv na vmist humusu [Energy-saving methods of the main tillage in the cultivation of winter wheat and their influence on the humus content]. In: Agrarian science and practice: Achievements and development prospects: Proceedings of V International Scientific and Practical Conference. Bila Tserkva. Pp. 228–230 (in Ukrainian).
Hololobova, O. (2010). Humusovyi stan gruntu yak pokaznyk agroefektyvnosti sposobiv obrobitku gruntu [Humus conditions of the soil as a marker of soil tillage agroefficiency]. In: Ohorona dovkillia. Proceedings of the V Ukrainian Scientific Taliyev Readings. Kharkiv. Pp. 45–52 (in Ukrainian).
Israel, H., & Richter, R. R. (2011). A guide to understanding meta-analysis. Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy, 41(7), 496–504.
Lakkireddy, K. K. R., Kasturi, K., & Sambasiva Rao, K. R. S. (2012). Role of hydroponics and aeroponics in soilless culture in commercial food production. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 1(1), 26–35.
Lal, R. (1993). Tillage effects on soil degradation, soil resilience, soil quality, and sustainability. Soil and Tillage Research, 27(1–4), 1–8.
Li, Y., Li, Z., Cui, S., Jagadamma, S., & Zhang, Q. (2019). Residue retention and minimum tillage improve physical environment of the soil in croplands: A global meta-analysis. Soil and Tillage Research, 194, 104292.
Liu, X., Wu, X., Liang, G., Zheng, F., Zhang, M., & Li, S. (2021). A global meta-analysis of the impacts of no-tillage on soil aggregation and aggregate-associated organic carbon. Land Degradation and Development, 32(18), 5292–5305.
Lykhovyd, P. V. (2024). Biological activity of soils in Ukraine depending on tillage options: A meta-analysis. Regulatory Mechanisms in Biosystems, 15(1), 119–128.
Morozov, O., & Isachenko, S. (2018). Vplyv gruntozberihaiuchykh tekhnolohiy system obrobitku na rodiuchist’ gruntu v umovakh stepu Ukrayiny (na prykladi Zaporiz’koyi oblasti) [Effect of soil-saving technologies of tillage on soil fertility inb the conditions of the steppe of Ukraine (on the example of Zaporizhzhia region)]. In: Radieva, M. M., & Kolomiets, V. M. (Eds.). Ekolohiya – philosophiya isnuvannia liudstva [Ecology – philosophy of existence of mankind]. Color Print Publishing, Melitopol. Pp. 79–81 (in Ukrainian).
Nunes, M. R., Karlen, D. L., Veum, K. S., Moorman, T. B., & Cambardella, C. A. (2020). Biological soil health indicators respond to tillage intensity: A US meta-analysis. Geoderma, 369, 114335.
Parr, J. F., Papendick, R. I., Hornick, S. B., & Meyer, R. E. (1992). Soil quality: Attributes and relationship to alternative and sustainable agriculture. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 7(1–2), 5–11.
Pereira, P., Bašić, F., Bogunovic, I., & Barcelo, D. (2022). Russian-Ukrainian war impacts the total environment. Science of the Total Environment, 837, 155865.
Pikovska, O. V. (2012). Vplyv riznykh system obrobitku gruntu na vmist i dynamiku humusu chornozemu zvychainoho [Effect of different systems of soil tillage on humus contents and dynamics in typical chornozem]. Scientific Herald of the National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine, Series Agronomy, 176, 170–173 (in Ukrainian).
Popa, M., Lațo, A., Corcheș, M., Radulov, I., Berbecea, A., Crista, F., Nita, L., Lato, K. I., & Popa, D. (2016). Quality of some soils from the western region of Romania. AgroLife Scientific Journal, 5(1), 174–177.
Remeniuk, Y. O. (2010). Vplyv tryvaloho obrobitku gruntu na rodiuchist’ chornozemu typovoho [Effect of continuous soil tillage on the fertility of typical chornozem]. Herald of Agricultural Science, 11, 14–17 (in Ukrainian).
Solokha, M., Pereira, P., Symochko, L., Vynokurova, N., Demyanyuk, O., Sementsova, K., Inacio, M., & Barcelo, D. (2023). Russian-Ukrainian war impacts on the environment. Evidence from the field on soil properties and remote sensing. Science of the Total Environment, 902, 166122.
Tanchyk, S. P., & Yamkovyi, V. Y. (2010). Humusnyi stan chornozemu typovoho zalezhno vid obrobitku hruntu [Humus state of typical chornozem depending on soil tillage]. Scientific Collection of the Institute of Agriculture of UAAS, 1–2, 39–45 (in Ukrainian).
Tkachenko, M., Zadubynna, Y., Kondratіuk, I., Tsiuk, O., & Tarasenko, O. (2024). Zminy vmistu humusu ta fizyko-khimichnykh vlastyvostey chornozemu typovoho zalezhno vid system obrobitku ta mineralnoho udobrennia [Changes in humus content and physicochemical properties of typical chornozem depending on cultivation and mineral fertilizer systems]. Herald of Agricultural Science, 850, 16–22 (in Ukrainian).
Tkachuk, V. P., & Trofymenko, P. I. (2020). Vmist humusu za riznoho vykorystannia dernovo-pidzolystoho supishchanoho gruntu ta obsiahy emisiinykh vtrat CO2 [Humus content for different use of sod-podzolic sandy soil and the amount of CO2 emission lost]. Scientific Reports of the National University of Environmental and Life Sciences of Ukraine, 2, 84 (in Ukrainian).
Topa, D., Cara, I. G., & Jităreanu, G. (2021). Long term impact of different tillage systems on carbon pools and stocks, soil bulk density, aggregation and nutrients: A field meta-analysis. Catena, 199, 105102.
Tsandur, M. O. (2008). Dynamika vmistu humusu v chornozemi pivdennomu pid vplyvom system obrobitku gruntu i poperednykiv [Dynamic of humus content in the southern black soil under the influence of a system of preparing the soil]. Scientific and Methodical Journal, 81, 39–42 (in Ukrainian).
Tsvei, Y. P., Levchenko, L. M., & Tyshchenko, M. V. (2020). Formuvannia rodiuchosti chornozemu slabosolontsiuvatoho za dovhotryvaloyi systemy udobrennia i obrobitku hruntu v korotkorotatsiyni sivozminy [Fertility of slightly saline chernozem under the effect of long-term fertilization system and tillage method in short crop rotation]. Scientific Papers of the Institute of Bioenergy Crops and Sugar Beet, 28, 20–28 (in Ukrainian).
Ugarte, C. M., Kwon, H., Andrews, S. S., & Wander, M. M. (2014). A meta-analysis of soil organic matter response to soil management practices: An approach to evaluate conservation indicators. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 69(5), 422–430.
Zhang, X., Lu, S., Wang, C., Zhang, A., & Wang, X. (2021). Optimization of tillage rotation and fertilization increased the soil organic carbon pool and crop yield in a semiarid region. Land Degradation and Development, 32(18), 5241–5252.
Zhuravel, S. V., Kravchuk, M. M., Kravchuk, N. N., Kropyvnytskyi, R. B., Kropyvnytskyi, R. B., & Kravchuk, T. V. (2009). Zmina humusnoho stanu i vmistu luzhnohidrolizovanoho azotu za riznykh system udobrennia ta obrobitku v sivozmini [Changes in humus conditions and content of hydrolyzed nitrogen under different systems of fertilization and tillage in the crop rotation]. Herald of Zhytomyr National Agroecological University, 2, 95–103 (in Ukrainian).
Zubenok, O. V. (2012). Vplyv sposobiv osnovnoho obrobitku na vmist humusu v chornozemi typovomu ta biolohichnu aktyvnist’ gruntu [Effect of tillage on humus content in typical chornozem and soil biological activity]. Herald of Sumy National Agrarian University, Series: Agronomy and Biology, 2, 94–97 (in Ukrainian).
Zvedeniuk, T. B., Havrylov, S. O., & Tarariko, N. M. (2014). Produktyvnist’ zernovoyi sivozminy ta rodiuchist’ siroho lisovoho gruntu za riznykh system osnovnoho obrobitku [The productivity of grain crop-rotation and gray-forest soil fertility with use different systems of basic tillage]. Agriculture, 1–2, 24–27 (in Ukrainian).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons «Attribution» 4.0 License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
